Can I Just Use a Spreadsheet to Track Candidates?

You absolutely can use a spreadsheet to track candidates. In fact, many small businesses and startups rely on Microsoft Excel or Google Sheets in the early stages of their hiring processes. They’re convenient, accessible, and a tool most people are familiar with. At Aplii, we’ve walked down this path ourselves, but it's also one of the primary reasons we ventured into creating a dedicated applicant tracking system (ATS). As versatile as spreadsheets are, they eventually hit their limits when it comes to managing ongoing and complex recruitment processes. If you're still on the fence about shifting from spreadsheets to a more specialized solution, allow me to share some insights about the challenges you might face as your talent management needs grow.

The Initial Appeal of Spreadsheets in Candidate Tracking

Spreadsheets like Excel and Google Sheets are initially appealing because they offer a simple, cost-effective solution for tracking information. You don’t need special software or deep training to get started. You can easily create a new spreadsheet, enter candidate data, and share it with colleagues. It’s as straightforward as it sounds, which is why many opt for this approach initially.

However, let's delve into why relying solely on spreadsheets for candidate management is only a short-term fix.

1. Limited Data Management Capabilities

Spreadsheets start becoming problematic when you need to track a myriad of data points beyond names and contact information. In the hiring process, this often means juggling resumes, cover letters, portfolios, video calls, interviews, feedback notes, emails, and more. As you begin to expand your hiring funnel, the complexity grows exponentially. Sorting through hundreds of rows and columns to find specific data can become a cumbersome and time-consuming task.

In contrast, a robust ATS can handle vast amounts of data with efficiency and ease, allowing for sophisticated search and filtering options that help you find the information you need without hassle.

2. Collaboration and Real-Time Updates

While Google Sheets offers real-time collaboration to an extent, it’s not always reliable, especially when multiple users are editing at once. Excel, when used offline, doesn't provide this capability at all. Candidates’ information needs to be updated regularly, and if multiple team members are involved in the recruitment process, keeping sheets synchronized can be practically impossible.

An ATS designed for recruitment purposes provides seamless collaboration features, ensuring that everyone involved is working from the most up-to-date information. Notifications, real-time updates, and change histories keep all team members aligned.

3. Lack of Integration with Other Tools

In any modern recruitment process, integration with other tools, such as email clients, calendars, and HR systems, is crucial. While workarounds exist, no native functionality within Excel or Google Sheets allows for easy integration with these systems. This requires manual data uploads, which can lead to potential errors and data mismatches.

Specialized applicant tracking systems are built with integrations in mind, making it effortless to sync interviews with calendars, send automated emails to candidates, and much more, thereby streamlining the entire recruitment workflow.

4. Data Security Concerns

Candidate information is sensitive and must be protected. Spreadsheets are not designed with robust security measures in mind, especially when shared via email or stored on unsecured drives. This is even more concerning considering data protection regulations like GDPR.

An ATS offers enhanced security features, such as encrypted data storage and role-based access controls, so that you can confidently protect candidate information and maintain compliance with relevant data protection laws.

5. Reporting and Analytics

Understanding the efficacy of your hiring process is crucial. While you can create some basic charts and reports using Excel or Google Sheets, obtaining meaningful insights requires serious spreadsheet wizardry. As a result, valuable recruitment metrics can be overlooked or misunderstood.

An ATS can automatically generate insightful analytics and reports from your candidates' data, allowing you to make decisions based on real-time information and trends within your talent pipeline.

6. Scalability

As your company grows, so does your recruitment activity. Spreadsheets often become insufficient to manage the increased volume and complexity. You might experience slower loading times, crashes, and a more significant margin for errors as the data scales.

In contrast, an ATS is built to handle scale. It can efficiently manage growing lists of candidates and correspondingly evolving recruitment processes, enabling you to continue focusing on your core tasks.

Conclusion: Why Move Beyond Spreadsheets?

While spreadsheets such as Excel and Google Sheets may be practical for managing candidate data in the early stages, they are not a long-term solution once your hiring needs increase. Transitioning to an applicant tracking system like Aplii can save your team time and ensure no detail falls through the cracks. You will benefit from seamless integrations, real-time collaboration, enhanced data security, comprehensive reporting, and the capacity to scale effortlessly.

Ultimately, an ATS system like Aplii is not just about managing candidate information; it’s about improving the overall candidate experience, optimizing your recruitment process, and paving the way for your organization’s growth and success. So, while spreadsheets can get the job done in a pinch, they’ll certainly make the journey a lot bumpier than it needs to be.

• See if Aplii can help you build a talent pipeline